Philosophy of Mathematics: Structure and Ontology by Stewart Shapiro

By Stewart Shapiro

Publish yr note: First released in 1997

Do numbers, units, etc, exist? What do mathematical statements suggest? Are they actually precise or fake, or do they lack fact values altogether? Addressing questions that experience attracted full of life debate lately, Stewart Shapiro contends that normal realist and antirealist bills of arithmetic are either problematic.

As Benacerraf first famous, we're faced with the subsequent strong trouble. the specified continuity among mathematical and, say, medical language indicates realism, yet realism during this context indicates likely intractable epistemic difficulties. As a manner out of this difficulty, Shapiro articulates a structuralist technique. in this view, the subject material of mathematics, for instance, isn't a hard and fast area of numbers autonomous of one another, yet relatively is the normal quantity constitution, the trend universal to any approach of gadgets that has an preliminary item and successor relation pleasurable the induction precept. utilizing this framework, realism in arithmetic may be preserved with out complicated epistemic consequences.

Shapiro concludes by means of exhibiting how a structuralist procedure will be utilized to wider philosophical questions similar to the character of an "object" and the Quinean nature of ontological dedication. transparent, compelling, and tautly argued, Shapiro's paintings, noteworthy either in its try to boost a full-length structuralist method of arithmetic and to track its emergence within the heritage of arithmetic, can be of deep curiosity to either philosophers and mathematicians.

Show description

Read Online or Download Philosophy of Mathematics: Structure and Ontology PDF

Best philosophy books

A Companion to Heidegger (Blackwell Companions to Philosophy)

A significant other to Heidegger is an entire consultant to the paintings and regarded Martin Heidegger, essentially the most influential philosophers of the 20 th century.
The quantity opens via targeting an important parts of Heidegger’s highbrow biography, together with his infamous involvement with nationwide Socialism. The e-book then is going directly to supply a scientific and accomplished exploration of Heidegger’s paintings. The contributions continue chronologically, beginning with discussions of his magnum opus Being and Time, relocating directly to the interval of his ‘Kehre’ or ‘turn’, and concluding along with his overlooked later paintings. a last part comprises key serious responses to Heidegger’s philosophy, together with attention of his relation to pragmatism, faith, and ecology. individuals contain some of the major interpreters of, and commentators on, the paintings of Heidegger.


What is required for whatever new to seem? in keeping with Gilles Deleuze, some of the most great modern philosophers, this question of "novelty" is the main challenge posed by way of Bergson's paintings. during this significant other booklet to Bergson's subject and reminiscence, Deleuze demonstrates either the improvement and the diversity of 3 basic Bergsonian recommendations: length, reminiscence, and the élan very important. Bergsonism is additionally very important to an knowing of Deleuze's personal paintings, prompted because it is through Bergson. Gilles Deleuze is Professor of Philosophy on the college of Paris VIII, Vincennes/Saint Denis. between his latest books in translation are Nietzsche and Philosophy, Cinema: picture move and, with Felix Guattari, Anti-Oedipus, Kafka, and a thousand Plateaus. Hugh Tomlinson is the translator of Deleuze's Nietzsche and Philosophy and Kant's severe Philosophy. Barbara Habberjam is a translator residing in England.

Gramsci and Educational Thought (Educational Philosophy and Theory Special Issues)

Via a chain of writings from foreign students, Gramsci and academic notion can pay tribute to the tutorial impact of Antonio Gramsci, certainly one of the best social thinkers and political theorists of the 20 th century. Represents sound social thought and a extensive software and reinvention of Gramsci’s ideasCovers very important parts similar to language and schooling, group schooling, and social paintings educationFeatures views from diversified geographical contexts

Philosophy and the Origin and Evolution of the Universe

It has usually been famous form of double dynamics char- terizes the improvement of technological know-how. at the one hand the development in each self-discipline seems because the final result of an expanding specialization, implying the restrict of the inquiry to very partial fields or elements of a given area. nevertheless, an contrary (but one may possibly larger say a complementary) pattern issues in the direction of the development of theoretical frameworks of serious ge- rality, the purpose of which turns out to correspond now not a lot to the necessity of delivering «explanations» for the main points collected via partial research, as to the need of accomplishing an - rizon of world comprehension of the entire box.

Additional resources for Philosophy of Mathematics: Structure and Ontology

Sample text

Similarly, can one tell from surface grammar alone that an expression like dx is not a singular term that denotes a mathematical object, whereas dy/dx may very well denote something (a function, not a quotient)? The history of analysis shows a long and tortuous process of showing just what expressions like this mean. Of course, mathematics can often go on quite well without this interpretive work, and sometimes the interpretive work is premature and is a distraction at best. Berkeley’s famous and logically penetrating critique of analysis was largely ignored among mathematicians—so long as they knew “how to go on,” as Wittgenstein might put it.

In the present context, the “rules” are classical logic, impredicative definition, and the like. Advocates of the weaker forms of working realism hold that the practice of mathematics is rule-describable, whereas the strong normative version takes mathematics to be rulefollowing activity. Of course, there are a number of distinctions to be made here: rules can be explicit or implicit, conscious or unconscious; and there are Wittgensteinian criticisms of rule-following to be dealt with. 4. Questions about what is interesting and worthy of pursuit have ramifications for methodology and for the development of mathematics.

It would probably beg the present question to reject the philosophy-first principle just because it is not true to mathematical practice, or to the history of mathematics. One can always concede the “data” of practice and history, while maintaining a normative claim that mathematics ought to be dominated by philosophy and, with Plato, Bishop, and others, be critical of mathematicians when they neglect or violate the true philosophical first principles. To pursue this normative claim, the philosopher might formulate a telos for mathematics and then argue either that mathematicians do not accept this telos but should, or else that mathematicians implicitly accept it but do not act in accordance with it.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.72 of 5 – based on 5 votes

Author: admin